DO NOT EVER DO THIS!
I am about to show you the worst core exercise you have ever seen!
It shows a “doctor” prescribing an advanced core exercise. The problem is he is going into extreme hyperextension. This position repeated over and over can cause spondylolisthesis and even spondylolysis.
Repetitive Hyperextension ==> Spondylolisthesis
Simple Definitions:
Spondylolisthesis – vertebral slippage
Spondylolysis – fracture
Here is a great explaination from Cassandra Forsythe I pulled from Mike Robertson’s site.
“Spondylolisthesis is a spinal instability condition that affects the posterior elements of the spinal vertebrae, also known as the lamina. These lamina attach to the vertebrae via the pedicles; and, at the top and bottom of the lamina, are the facet joints. The facet joints provide static stability, and to a lesser extent, help with load bearing. However, the main load-bearing piece of the spine is the strong vertebral body. For people who have extensive lumbar lordosis, or participate in activities that involve repeated lumbar hyper extension, especially under a considerable load (like gymnasts and weightlifters), the load-bearing responsibilities are shifted away from the vertebrae and placed upon the smaller posterior spinal structures (the lamina and facet joints). Since these relatively weaker posterior elements aren’t designed to deal with this kind of load, they eventually succumb to the stress and become fractured. When the fracture occurs on one side of the spinal vertebrae, the result is termed spondylolysis.”
So, here it is, the worst core exercise video ever produced:
Here are some more references:
“Athletes who participate in sports involving repeated and forceful hyperextension of the spine may suffer from lumbar facet syndrome, spondylolysis, or spondylolisthesis.” (Reference 2)
For your complete reference for real core strength and core workouts visit Combat Core Strength
Or pick up the best selling DVD! They call it the best core training DVD on the market!
How to Build Muscle | Muscle Building Workouts | How to Lose Fat | Six Pack Abs | Build Muscle, Muscle Gaining Workouts | Build Muscle Membership Site
Articles You Might Also Like:
15 Responses to “DO NOT EVER DO THIS!”
Leave a Reply
July 2nd, 2009 at 12:12 am
Doctor in what? stupidity?
He’s not repping CrossFit too well either.
July 2nd, 2009 at 1:23 am
What about training for back flexibility such as bridges and any sort of walk over? Do those damage the spine in the manner displayed in the video?
July 2nd, 2009 at 1:49 am
This is by far the worst thing for my back… He seems to get away with it (at least for the time being), but one rep and I’d be out for a month. One favor please sir: Could you please talk about how this differs from back bridging (which has a similar ROM, but is more static in nature and involves different muscles contracting)?
July 2nd, 2009 at 6:42 am
Before I even started the video and just saw the exercise description, I thought of Crossfit, and low and behold, it is a CF guy. If you say anything to those people they defend it like crazy.
What about Gymnasts though? They do that from the time they are little. What about some Yoga poses? Are those the same?
Laurel
July 2nd, 2009 at 7:40 am
Kane,
Yes flexibility in the back is good if you define where the flexibility originates.
Flexibility in lower lumbar = bad
Flexibility in the mid-upper thoracic = good
_____________________________________
Laurel,
Yes, there is a high risk for gymnastic and those who participate in yoga asanas that promote flexibility in the segments of the lower lumbar.
July 2nd, 2009 at 8:00 am
When I saw him getting set up, I was thinking, “ooooh nooo”.
ahhaah.
Gee, let’s hyperextend the lumbar spine and then use a forceful, aggressive contraction to rapidly pull us into lumbar flexion (possibly with a rotation). At the top of the movement he is practically in a slump test position!
July 2nd, 2009 at 8:09 am
Wow that hurts just looking at it! I like how he says not to do it if you have a weak back. I think if you didn’t have one, you would by the end of that set.
July 2nd, 2009 at 9:36 am
In reference to Laurel, how is this a Crossfit guy? The video I see is for bender ball?
July 2nd, 2009 at 10:41 am
Laurel,
Spody’s are very common in gymnasts due to what you said in conjunction with forceful repeated landings.
July 2nd, 2009 at 10:46 am
Smitty,
My question is in regards to Cassandra’s reference to “weight lifting.” Is she referring to the actual sport or to lifting weights in general? I’d like to say that this would be due to technical flaw, which you don’t see very often in advanced weight lifters, but you would see in a gym with people who don’t really understand how they are to set up for specific lifts. What are your thoughts? And what situations would you see in training (athlete’s or the general public) that could lead to issues this severe?
July 2nd, 2009 at 11:22 am
Did I miss something or did this video change? I see an ad for something ridiculaous called a Bender ball. Nothing with a doctor as decsribed in the text.
July 2nd, 2009 at 11:45 am
Yes, the video changed, it was taken down from Youtube.
Demayo: I believe she’s talking about the sport. She is either referring to:
– inexperienced weightlifters who achieve extension not in the segments buffered by the longissimus but rather in the lower lumbar (L1-L5). If you look at experience weightlifters and powerlifters this muscle (longissimus) is hypertrophied like crazy because they are distributing the load correctly.
July 2nd, 2009 at 12:29 pm
So the benderball is bad? The video has changed. Why was it replaced by the bender ball? Is it because the ball pushes into the spine? I’d very much like to know what the original exercise was. Can you describe it?
Back bends are done in yoga, but we are always taught not to bend the lower back (at least the good yoga teachers say this). The bend is actually supposed to come from the thoracic spine. They call these “heart openers”. If you don’t open the heart, the lower back collapses and and that is very bad.
July 10th, 2009 at 4:23 pm
How can you say it’s the worst exercise when it’s 408% more effective? And you just have to use a freakin’ ball?
Hilarious!
March 5th, 2010 at 8:56 pm
are weighted hyperextensions safe?